Paradigmatic Dialectics in the Criminal Law Policy of Carbon Trading: Constructing the Gradatum Remedium Principle Based on Pancasila Justice
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61194/law.v4i2.1050Keywords:
carbon trading governance, environmental criminal law policy, gradatum remedium principle, pancasila justiceAbstract
Carbon trading has emerged as a key instrument for climate change mitigation, yet its distinctive legal characteristics - intangible, registry-based, technically verified, and tradable assets - create significant enforcement challenges. In Indonesia, although the regulatory framework for carbon economic value and carbon-market supervision has developed, the relationship between administrative, civil, and criminal enforcement remains insufficiently structured, creating uncertainty in responding to carbon-market violations. This study examines the paradigmatic tension between the Ultimum Remedium principle, which positions criminal law as a last resort, and the Primum Remedium principle, which supports early criminal intervention for serious environmental harm. Using normative legal research with statutory, conceptual, philosophical, and limited comparative approaches, this study analyzes Indonesian carbon-trading, environmental, financial-sector, and criminal-law regulations. The findings indicate that Indonesia does not lack criminal-law provisions; rather, it lacks a carbon-market-specific enforcement framework that establishes clear and proportional escalation according to the gravity of violations. This study therefore constructs the Gradatum Remedium principle as a dialectical synthesis of Ultimum Remedium and Primum Remedium. The proposed principle establishes five levels of enforcement: (1) administrative correction and compliance; (2) civil liability and restitution; (3) light criminal sanctions for serious regulatory violations; (4) severe criminal sanctions for fraudulent, organized, or environmentally harmful conduct; and (5) additional sanctions, including asset confiscation, restoration, corporate compliance measures, and revocation of carbon-market rights. The framework integrates culpability, market integrity, MRV reliability, registry validity, financial-crime risks, and Pancasila justice. It provides a novel normative foundation for proportional and justice-oriented carbon-market enforcement in Indonesia.
References
Akbar, F. (2022). Protection of Indigenous Law Communities: A Sociological Legal Study. Hasanuddin University Press.
Ammara, N., & others. (n.d.). Implementation of Carbon Emission Trading in Realizing the Golden Indonesia.
Ammara, N., Trihandini, L. I., & Syafriadi, D. (2024). Implementasi Perdagangan Emisi Karbon dalam Rangka Perwujudan Transformasi Indonesia Emas. Jurnal Al Azhar Indonesia Seri Ilmu Sosial, 5(3). https://doi.org/10.36722/jaiss.v5i3.3042
Ayres, I., & Braithwaite, J. (1992). Responsive Regulation: Transcending the Deregulation Debate. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780195070705.001.0001 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780195070705.001.0001
Bayer, P., & Aklin, M. (2020). The European Union Emissions Trading System Reduced CO2 Emissions despite Low Prices. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(16), 8804–8812. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1918128117 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1918128117
Belenky, L. G., Iyadomi, K., Carevic, S. E. D., & Gadde, H. (2022). Digital Monitoring, Reporting, and Verification Systems and Their Application in Future Carbon Markets.
Budhijanto, D. (2014). Theory of Convergence Law. Refika Aditama.
Cahyani, F. (2024). Efektivitas Kebijakan Pajak Karbon dan Perdagangan Karbon di Indonesia: Studi Komparatif dengan Negara Singapura. Universitas Islam Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim.
Deatherage, S. D. (2011). Carbon Trading Law and Practice. Oxford University Press.
Dharmawan, I. W. S. (2022). Opportunities for Carbon Economic Value (NEK).
Diantha, I. M. P. (2016). Normative Legal Research Methodology: In Justification of Legal Theory. Prenada Media.
Financial Services Authority (OJK). (2023a). Circular Letter Number 12/SEOJK.04/2023 concerning the Organization of the Carbon Exchange.
Financial Services Authority (OJK). (2023b). Regulation Number 14 of 2023 concerning Carbon Trading through the Carbon Exchange.
Financial Services Authority (OJK). (2023c). The Quarterly Report on Indonesia Financial Sector Development: Q1 2023.
Fuady, M. (2020). Grand Theories in Law. Prenada Media.
Gunningham, N., Grabosky, P., & Sinclair, D. (1998). Smart Regulation: Designing Environmental Policy. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198268574.001.0001 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198268574.001.0001
Ibrahim, J. (2019). Theory and Methodology of Normative Legal Research. Bayumedia Publishing.
Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market. (2024). The Voluntary Carbon Market Explained.
INTERPOL. (2013). Guide to Carbon Trading Crime.
Journal of Al Azhar Indonesia. (2024). Transformation. In Journal of Al Azhar Indonesia, Social Sciences Series (Vol. 5, Number 3). https://doi.org/10.36722/jaiss.v5i3.3042 DOI: https://doi.org/10.36722/jaiss.v5i3.3042
Leong, R. Y. (2021). Correlation between Environmental Law and Sustainability Aspects in Tropical Countries. University of Malaya.
Margono. (2023). Principles of Justice, Utility, and Legal Certainty in Judicial Decisions. Sinar Grafika.
Marzuki, P. M. (2005). Legal Research. Kencana.
Mentari, N., & others. (2024). Implementation of Carbon Trading Regulations in Indonesia: Green Investment and Economic Constitution Perspectives. JATISWARA, 39(3). https://doi.org/10.29303/jtsw.v39i3.710
Mentari, N., Rafiqi, I. D., & Zein, T. (2024). Implementasi Pengaturan Perdagangan Karbon di Indonesia dalam Perspektif Investasi Hijau dan Konstitusi Ekonomi. JATISWARA, 39(3), 283–294. https://doi.org/10.29303/jtsw.v39i3.710 DOI: https://doi.org/10.29303/jtsw.v39i3.710
Mochtar, Z. A., & Hiariej, E. O. S. (2023). Fundamentals of Legal Science: Understanding Legal Norms, Theory, Principles, and Philosophy. Rajawali Press.
Paniago, A. O. (2024). Aspek Hukum Sertifikat Pengurangan Emisi sebagai Objek Transaksi Perdagangan Karbon [Universitas Sriwijaya]. https://doi.org/10.28946/lexl.v7i3.4119 DOI: https://doi.org/10.28946/lexl.v7i3.4119
Poesoko, H. (2018). Legal Science in the Perspective of the Philosophy of Science. LaksBang Pressindo.
Posner, R. A. (1991). Economic Analysis of Law. Little, Brown and Company.
Prasetyo, T., & Barkatullah, A. H. (2020). Philosophy, Theory and Legal Science: Thoughts towards a Just and Dignified Society. RajaGrafindo Persada.
Prihatiningtyas, W., & others. (2023). Fairness Perspective in Carbon Trading Policy in Indonesia as an Effort to Overcome Climate Change: Legal Reflections. Journal of Legal Studies, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.24246/jrh.2022.v7.i2.p163-186
Prihatiningtyas, W., Wijoyo, S., Wahyuni, I., & Fitriana, Z. M. (2023). Perspektif Keadilan dalam Kebijakan Perdagangan Karbon (Carbon Trading) di Indonesia sebagai Upaya Mengatasi Perubahan Iklim. Refleksi Hukum: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 7(2), 163–186. https://doi.org/10.24246/jrh.2023.v7.i2.p163-186 DOI: https://doi.org/10.24246/jrh.2023.v7.i2.p163-186
PT Bursa Efek Indonesia. (2023). Decree of the Board of Directors of the Indonesia Stock Exchange (PT. BEI) Number Kep-0029/BEI/09-2023 concerning Regulations for the Use of Carbon Exchange Services.
Ramadhani, M. F. (2023). A Brief Sketch of Carbon Trading: Mechanisms and Regulations.
Republic of Indonesia. (2009). Law No. 32 of 2009 concerning Environmental Protection and Management.
Republic of Indonesia. (2010). Law No. 8 of 2010 concerning the Prevention and Eradication of Money Laundering.
Republic of Indonesia. (2016). Law Number 16 of 2016 concerning Ratification of the Paris Agreement.
Republic of Indonesia. (2021). Presidential Regulation Number 98 of 2021 concerning the Implementation of Carbon Economic Value to Achieve Nationally Determined Contribution Targets and Control Greenhouse Gas Emissions in National Development.
Republic of Indonesia. (2022). Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation Number 21 of 2022 concerning Procedures for Implementing Carbon Economic Value.
Republic of Indonesia. (2023a). Law No. 1 of 2023 concerning the Criminal Code. https://doi.org/10.61996/law.v1i2.36 DOI: https://doi.org/10.61996/law.v1i2.36
Republic of Indonesia. (2023b). Law No. 4 of 2023 concerning the Development and Strengthening of the Financial Sector.
Republic of Indonesia. (2023c). Minister of Environment and Forestry Regulation Number 7 of 2023 concerning Procedures for Carbon Trading in the Forestry Sector.
Republic of Indonesia. (2025). Presidential Regulation No. 110 of 2025 concerning the Implementation of Carbon Economic Value Instruments and National Greenhouse Gas Emission Control.
Situmeang, M. E. D. (2023). Problems of Carbon Trading Regulation in Indonesia. Universitas Pelita Harapan.
Soekanto, S., & Mamudji, S. (2010). Normative Legal Research: A Brief Overview. RajaGrafindo Persada.
Soeroso, R. (2021). Introduction to Legal Science. Sinar Grafika.
Susanti, D. I. (2019). Legal Interpretation: Theory and Method. Sinar Grafika.
Wibisana, A. G., & Cornelius, C. M. (2021). Climate Change Litigation in Indonesia. In J. Peel & H. M. Osofsky (Eds.), Climate Change Litigation in the Asia Pacific (pp. 234–260). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108777810.011 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108777810.011
World Bank. (2022). State and Trends of Carbon Pricing 2022. https://doi.org/10.1596/978-1-4648-1895-0 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1596/978-1-4648-1895-0
World Bank. (2024). Country Guidance for Navigating Carbon Markets.
Yoel, S. M., Priyono, F. X. J., Samekto, F. X. A., & Nurbani, E. (2024). Legal Reform on Indonesia’s Carbon Trading Regulation: Implementation and Harmonization of International Law. Journal of Law and Legal Reform, 6(4). https://doi.org/10.15294/jllr.v6i4.20009
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Sinergi International Journal of Law
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
